These Three Restaurants Each Claim to be the Oldest on Staten Island

Much like the controversy behind the oldest bar in New York City, there are three establishments which each claim to be the oldest on Staten Island. In this funny recent episode of "The Most" series from our friends at the Staten Island Advance, watch as host Shane DiMaio tries to get to the bottom of it by visiting the owners of Killmeyer's, Liedy's, and Basilio Inn.

Killmeyer's, Liedy's or Basilio Inn: Which one is the oldest restaurant on Staten Island? Shane tries to find out. (Video by Alex Salmieri)

Matt Coneybeare

Matt Coneybeare

Editor in Chief

Matt enjoys exploring the City's with his partner and son. He is an avid marathon runner, and spends most of his time eating, running, and working on cool stuff.

Something wrong with this post? Let us know!

Brought To You By…